1 year ago
Matter Labs CEO Alex Gluchowski described Polygon Zero’s allegation that zkSync copied their codification without due attribution arsenic “unfounded, misleading, and highly disappointing,” according to an Aug. 4 post connected X, formerly Twitter.
Polygon’s plagiarism accusation
On Aug. 3, Polygon Zero said Matter Labs copied “performance-critical components” of its Plonky2 zero-knowledge strategy codification without due attribution.
The Polygon squad stated that the zkSync squad made misleading claims astir its latest proving strategy Boojum being 10x faster than Plonky2. It argued that this was impossible, considering Boojum copied the show codification of Plonky2.
Polygon Zero further powerfully criticized these actions, saying they were antithetical to the halfway principles of the open-source movement. According to the team, specified practices could airs a important menace to smaller improvement teams, arsenic “better-funded competitors” mightiness exploit their efforts without giving owed credit.
Matter Labs denial
In response, Gluchowski said claims that zkSync reused codification without attribution could not beryllium further from the truth.
According to Gluchoswki, Plonky2 and Boojum are implementations of the RedShift construction, which the Matter Labs squad introduced 3 years earlier Polygon Zero released the Plonky2 paper.
Although Polygon referred to RedShift successful the paper, Gluchowski said the squad did not springiness immoderate recognition to Matter Labs.
He explained that lone astir 5% of Boojum codification is based connected Plonky2 code, and the squad acknowledged Plonky2 successful the README record and the instauration post.
However, helium admitted that zkSync could person handled this amended and utilized a much modular attack for attribution, which would beryllium done subsequently. But helium criticized the nationalist allegations arsenic against the tone of Open Source.
“If the Polygon Zero squad wanted further credit, the easiest mode would person been to taxable a propulsion petition which we would person happily accepted.”
Meanwhile, Gluchowski expressed astonishment astir complaints regarding benchmarking. He noted that determination was nary request for the Polygon Zero squad to enactment retired its codification for benchmarking and endorse it if they were unhappy astir the benchmarking relation oregon un-optimizing their implementations.
The station Matter Labs CEO dismisses Polygon Zero claims of zkSync plagiarism appeared archetypal connected CryptoSlate.
English (US) 