Dogecoin ETF pushes crypto industry to embrace speculation

1 day ago

The archetypal US Dogecoin (DOGE) exchange-traded money (ETF) is acceptable to motorboat Thursday, dividing manufacture voices betwixt those calling it a breakthrough for crypto’s community-driven legitimacy and those dismissing it arsenic speculation successful a caller wrapper.

Unlike Bitcoin ETFs approved nether the Securities Act of 1933, the Rex-Osprey Dogecoin ETF (DOJE) won approval nether the Investment Company Act of 1940, a model typically utilized for communal funds and diversified ETFs.

BlackRock’s spot crypto fund, for instance, simply holds Bitcoin (BTC) successful Coinbase custody. DOJE alternatively gains vulnerability done a Cayman Islands subsidiary and derivatives since the 1940 enactment requires diversification and restricts single-asset concentration.

Crypto ETF debuts are usually celebrated by the industry, but critics reason that a memecoin money institutionalizes speculation — portion charging fees that investors could debar by buying Dogecoin directly. Some besides constituent to the irony that Dogecoin, which was created arsenic a joke, has leapfrogged projects with much tangible usage cases to the ETF stage.

Do we request a Dogecoin ETF?

Dogecoin is simply a descendant of Bitcoin. It was created successful 2013 arsenic a fork of Luckycoin, a fork of Litecoin, which is simply a fork of Bitcoin. While it began arsenic a joke, it has since grown into a top-10 cryptocurrency by marketplace capitalization.

Long embraced by retail traders, Dogecoin besides spawned the broader memecoin category, often criticized for its casino-like nature. That makes its support for an ETF particularly controversial.

An ETF lets investors summation vulnerability to Dogecoin done the banal market, but not everyone sees the point.

“These ETFs are charging off-the-charts fees erstwhile you could simply make a Coinbase relationship successful 5 minutes, bargain the token and ne'er beryllium charged an disbursal ratio,” Brian Huang, co-founder and CEO of crypto absorption level Glider, told Cointelegraph.

He added that organization investors are much apt to prioritize “legitimate” and revenue-generating tokens.

Dogecoin has elevated immoderate crypto investors into millionaires successful its history. But its terms is successful a changeless conflict with inflation. Dogecoin’s tokenomics were designed arsenic a satire of Bitcoin’s scarcity. Instead of a 21-million-coin cap, Dogecoin is unlimited and issues a 10,000-DOGE artifact reward each minute. That means astir 5 cardinal caller coins are minted yearly.

During past memecoin booms, analysts warned that specified assets diverted superior and attraction from much superior blockchain projects. Some spot the ETF arsenic reinforcing that problem.

“It’s chaotic to spot a memecoin front-run superior projects to the ETF decorativeness line,” Douglas Colkitt, a founding contributor astatine layer-1 blockchain Fogo, told Cointelegraph.

“An ETF wrapper doesn’t alteration the fundamentals; it conscionable lets Wall Street pump DOGE with a consecutive face.”

Dogecoin doesn’t unfastened up a crypto ETF free-for-all

By the extremity of August, 92 crypto ETPs had been awaiting SEC decisions from the Securities and Exchange Commission successful the US. Dogecoin products were among them, alongside different memecoin applications specified arsenic Pengu, the token tied to the non-fungible token (NFT) marque Pudgy Penguins.

“Dogecoin whitethorn person started arsenic a joke, but it’s go a superior altcoin that’s brought existent investors and engineers into the space,” said Mike Maloney, CEO and laminitis of Incyt. “Community engagement is arsenic existent for a coin arsenic it is for a stock.”

While critics similar Colkitt expressed vexation that a memecoin is front-running much superior projects, others reason its occurrence reflects crypto’s assemblage dynamics. Maja Vujinovic, CEO of Digital Assets astatine FG Nexus, told Cointelegraph that Dogecoin leapfrogging different altcoins shows however communities tin propulsion assets into regulated structures.

“If DOGE is first, it’s little astir method roadmaps and much astir acknowledging that communities themselves tin propulsion assets into regulated structures. That’s an important awesome regulators are responding to societal momentum arsenic overmuch arsenic marketplace cap,” she said.

Unlike galore altcoins, Dogecoin has often been successful the mainstream spotlight. Tesla CEO Elon Musk’s tweets successful 2021 sent its terms soaring, and a US authorities section helium erstwhile led was adjacent dubbed the Department of Government Efficiency, oregon DOGE. The token has besides endured aggregate carnivore markets, giving it a level of resilience and maturity that different memecoins lack.

“The ETF pathway won’t beryllium a free-for-all; liquidity, surveillance and custody readiness inactive acceptable the bar. But much tokens volition find their mode into regulated wrappers, which broadens adoption,” Vujinovic added.

On Tuesday, the SEC delayed its determination connected the Bitwise Dogecoin ETF, extending the reappraisal model to Nov. 12.

Dogecoin ETF blurs the enactment betwixt meme and market

A Dogecoin ETF forces the manufacture to face whether embracing speculation and civilization is portion of the package.

Skeptics reason the caller money leans excessively acold toward the latter. For Huang, the thought of wrapping a azygous token successful an ETF is “ridiculous,” the equivalent of packaging a lone banal arsenic a diversified product. To him, the Wall Street wrapper does small much than institutionalize a meme portion charging investors fees they could easy debar by buying DOGE directly.

Others antagonistic that signifier matters arsenic overmuch arsenic function. Vujinovic points retired that an ETF doesn’t change Dogecoin’s codification oregon purpose, but it does furniture successful custody, audits and disclosure requirements that adhd legitimacy for mainstream investors.

Colkitt sees the improvement arsenic some committedness and parody. If a memecoin tin marque it into a regulated ETF, past “anything is connected the table.” That could unfastened doors for adoption but besides highlights however crypto continues to blur the enactment betwixt breakthrough fiscal innovation and axenic entertainment.

In that sense, DOJE doesn’t reply whether memes beryllium successful superior markets, but it shows that regulators and investors alike are consenting to dainty them arsenic if they do.

Rex-Osprey has much memecoin ETFs successful the pipeline, with SEC filings outlining products tied to Official Trump (TRUMP) and Bonk (BONK), on with altcoins XRP (XRP) and Solana (SOL).

Magazine: Can Robinhood oregon Kraken’s tokenized stocks ever beryllium genuinely decentralized?

View source